If you’re looking for a high-end smart exercise bike, Peloton and NordicTrack are two of the most well-known companies to consider. Both companies offer intense workouts, cutting-edge technology, and the best cycling experience for the whole family. But with so many similarities, how do you decide which is the best investment? NordicTrack offers uphill and downhill rides for a more interactive outdoor cycling experience, while Peloton is known for its energetic live classes and strong community. Your choice should be based on factors such as cost, features, workout schedule, and overall experience. In this analogy, we’ll break down all the notable features so you can make an informed decision.
Price Comparison
One of the most important considerations when choosing a smart bike is the price. The regular Peloton Bike retails for $1,445, but that price doesn’t include the $44 monthly subscription fee required to participate in classes. The higher-end Peloton Bike+ ($2,495) offers automatic resistance changes and a rotating screen for off-bike workouts. NordicTrack’s S22i Studio Cycle retails for $1,399 and comes with a one-year iFIT membership, which gives you access to thousands of classes. After the first year, an iFIT subscription costs $39 per month. Peloton’s base price may seem lower, but higher subscription costs will make the device more expensive over time.
Design and Build Quality
Despite their different riding experiences, both Peloton and NordicTrack are built with high-quality materials. Because Peloton bikes are sleek and compact, they’re ideal for use in small spaces. The Bike+ models’ belt drive system makes for a quiet, smooth ride. The NordicTrack S22i, on the other hand, is larger but has an incline and decline mechanism so users can mimic real-world terrain. While the NordicTrack’s heavier flywheel provides a more consistent feel, the bike’s size can be a drawback for those with limited space.
Technology and Display
High-resolution displays enhance the workout experience; both the NordicTrack and Peloton excel in this area. The Bike+ has a larger 23.8-inch rotating display, while the standard Peloton Bike has a 21.5-inch HD touchscreen. For strength trainers and yoga practitioners, the NordicTrack S22i is more flexible, with a 22-inch HD touchscreen that also rotates 360 degrees. While both bikes offer a perfectly clear view, the NordicTrack’s screen customizability offers more options for off-bike workouts.
Workout Content and Program Changes
Peloton features industry-leading fitness trainers who add energy and motivation to every ride, and is known for its live and on-demand classes. The Peloton Leaderboard adds a competitive element and encourages users to challenge themselves. NordicTrack is a technology from iFIT that provides a live, scenic outdoor cycling experience, with the coach adjusting incline and resistance in real time. If you find intense, competitive group training very satisfying, Peloton is the best choice. However, if you prefer to ride outdoors and like automatic resistance control, NordicTrack offers a more realistic experience.
Obstacles and Incline Characteristics
The difficulty and dynamics of the workout depend largely on the changes in resistance level and incline. The Peloton bike has 100 levels of magnetic resistance for precise control. Only the Bike+ model offers automatic resistance adjustments. The NordicTrack S22i simulates real-world riding conditions, with resistance and incline/descent functions. During an iFIT workout, trainers can vary these parameters automatically, leaving their hands free. If you are looking for a bike that is very similar to outdoor bikes, the NordicTrack is an advantage.
Membership and Subscription Fees
In order to access their workout content, Peloton and NordicTrack charge their members an ongoing membership fee. For an all-access membership fee of $44 per month, Peloton offers thousands of live and on-demand classes. NordicTrack’s iFIT membership is a bit cheaper at $39 per month, and offers great rides and automatic adjustments on the trainer. For new users, NordicTrack also offers a free one-year subscription with the purchase of a bike, which is a great way to save money. NordicTrack is a more affordable option, as Peloton’s subscription fee can add up over time to the total cost.
Music and Entertainment Options
Music is the most important motivator for your workouts. Peloton has a big advantage here. Peloton partners with major music labels to offer carefully curated playlists featuring top artists and special music series. For those who are motivated by energetic playlists, NordicTrack is less appealing, as the emphasis is more on the workout experience than the music. If you train to music a lot during your workouts, Peloton is the best choice.
Which Bike is Best for Beginners?
For people who are new to structured routines and simple, easy-to-follow workouts, Peloton may be a better option. The site offers a variety of beginner-friendly classes, ensuring a smooth transition into the world of indoor cycling. While NordicTrack is suitable for beginners, beginning cyclists may find the more complex features (incline and decline adjustments) difficult. If you are just starting out, Peloton’s intensive classes and inspiring instructors are perfect for you.
Which Bike is Best for Advanced Cyclists?
NordicTrack’s advanced resistance control and realistic terrain simulation will appeal to experienced riders. The ability to adjust incline and descent speeds depending on outdoor conditions makes the workout more challenging. Peloton, on the other hand, offers competitive leaderboards and advanced power zone workouts that will motivate dedicated cyclists. If you like to challenge others, Peloton is a great choice. However, if you’re looking for an outdoor ride with a reasonable resistance variation, NordicTrack offers a much better experience.
Warranty and Customer Service
Peloton offers an optional extended protection plan with a 12-month limited warranty. While replacement parts can be expensive, customer service is usually very fast. NordicTrack offers a more extensive warranty, including a 10-year frame warranty, 2-year parts warranty, and 1-year labor warranty. The longer warranty makes NordicTrack a safer investment in terms of reliability and longevity.
Conclusion
Peloton and NordicTrack offer a premium home cycling experience, but your personal tastes and fitness goals will determine which one is right for you. If you’re into live events, community engagement, and premium music integration, Peloton is the perfect choice. If you’re looking for an outdoor cycling experience with uphill and downhill capabilities and an affordable subscription, NordicTrack is the way to go. No matter which bike you choose, investing in a smart bike is a step toward a better lifestyle.
FAQs
1. Is Peloton heavier than NordicTrack?
While both bikes have adjustable resistance, the NordicTrack’s incline and decline features provide an extra challenge similar to riding outdoors.
2. Can you use NordicTrack or Peloton without a subscription?
That’s true, but the experience is very limited. Without a subscription, you won’t have access to interactive lessons or trainer-driven adjustments.
3. Who has better instructors, Peloton or NordicTrack?
NordicTrack’s iFIT emphasizes outdoor training with professional athletes, while Peloton is known for its high-profile, energetic instructors.
4. Which of these bikes has the best resale value?
Peloton generally holds its resale value better due to high community demand and brand recognition.
5. Can I wear NordicTrack Peloton shoes?
NordicTrack is compatible with SPD cleats; Peloton bikes use LOOK Delta cleats.
